In the world of superhero franchises, there's a trope that often rears its head, and it's one that can be incredibly frustrating for fans. The 'it's in their DNA' explanation for a character's inherent power is a lazy narrative device that fails to satisfy curious audiences. This trope has been used time and time again, and it's high time we delve into why it's so problematic.
The Frustrating DNA Trope
The latest example of this trope can be found in HBO Max's 'Lanterns' series, where the origin story of John Stewart, a powerful Green Lantern, is explored. The show hints at John's immense power, but when it comes to explaining why he's so special, the answer is simply, 'it's in his genes.' This is a cop-out, and it leaves viewers with more questions than answers.
A Lack of Depth
What makes this trope particularly annoying is that it lacks depth and imagination. It's a quick fix for writers, a way to introduce a powerful character without putting in the effort to craft a compelling backstory. By attributing a character's abilities to their DNA, the story becomes predictable and uninspired. It's a missed opportunity to explore unique character traits, personal journeys, and the development of extraordinary skills.
The Power of Potential
In 'Lanterns,' John Stewart's father, John Sr., is selected by the Power Ring, but his fear causes him to be passed over. However, the ring's interest in him suggests there's something special in his genetic makeup. This raises an intriguing question: what if potential, rather than inherent power, is the true indicator of a hero's worth? This idea could add a layer of complexity to the story, exploring the idea that anyone, with the right training and mindset, could become a powerful force for good.
A Missed Opportunity
The 'Lanterns' series has the potential to explore this concept further, especially with the death of Hal Jordan, leaving John to step into a more prominent role. However, if the show continues to rely on the 'it's in his DNA' trope, it risks becoming a generic superhero tale. Audiences crave depth and complexity, and this trope fails to deliver.
A Call for Change
As a fan and analyst, I believe it's time for a shift in narrative. We've seen this trope in various franchises, from 'Spider-Man' to 'Star Wars,' and it's time to move beyond it. Writers should focus on crafting compelling characters with unique journeys, rather than relying on genetic predispositions. By doing so, they can create more engaging and memorable stories that resonate with audiences.
Final Thoughts
The 'it's in their DNA' trope is a lazy narrative device that fails to capture the imagination. It's a shortcut that writers should avoid, opting instead for more creative and thought-provoking explanations for a character's power. 'Lanterns' has the potential to explore this concept further, and I hope the show takes this opportunity to deliver a more satisfying and engaging story.
